Connecting University Circle
Brought to You by PNC

Share This

Close

« back to news list

San Francisco uses parking spaces to gamify mobility

Posted April 03, 2018 in Articles

Author: Ethan Goffman

It’s no secret that San Francisco is growing. The California city is projected to add some 190,000 jobs and 100,000 homes by 2040 – which means massive congestion.

To brace themselves, the city is requiring that new construction build fewer parking spaces, or else encourage alternatives to solo car trips, by using a Transportation Demand Management (TDM) points system.

For an eligible building, the number of parking spaces is cross-indexed against building type—retail, office, residential or other—to create a target number of points. Having more parking spaces mandates more TDM measures. For instance, a residential building with five or fewer spaces must provide 10 points worth of TDM measures, while one with 16 to 20 spaces must provide 13 points of such measures.

Points can be earned by subsidizing transit or bikeshare; improving walking conditions; adding biking facilities; providing car share membership; adding van pools, shuttles, or car sharing; unbundling parking; adding on-site affordable housing; and a few other measures. So, for instance, bicycle parking can be worth 1 to 4 points.

This isn’t the first program to “gamify” TDM: Arlington Transportation Partners has used the Champions program to successfully encourage Arlington organizations to adopt TDM practices, like biking and carsharing.

But San Francisco’s incentive system is the first mandatory one. “This is actually a regulatory program,” said Corey Teague, Assistant Zoning Administrator of the San Francisco Planning Department. In other words, the city has mandated certain standards that eligible buildings must meet.

However, “project sponsors or property owners get to choose how they meet their requirements,” said Audrey Harris, Transportation Demand Management Performance Manager of the San Francisco Planning Department. Buildings can design an individual plan based on circumstances and preferences.

For the TDM program to apply, a new construction must have at least 10 dwelling units or bedrooms if it’s residential or 10,000 square feet if it’s non-residential. In addition, buildings that change use—say, from a warehouse to an office building—must follow the TDM program if they occupy at least 25,000 square feet.

Because the plan only came into effect recently—it is “a year young,” said Harris—the monitoring process has just begun and it is too early to draw conclusions about its effectiveness.

Therefore, San Francisco will be closely following up, gathering data, to learn as much as possible about best practices. “One of the great things about this program,” said Teague, is that “as more and more projects come online” the city will gather data and analysis to answer what “is most effective and why.” Measures then can be improved, and data concerning best practices can be shared.

Direct measurements, for instance of bicycle trips caused by specific building plans, are difficult. Therefore, monitoring will depend largely on intercept surveys, where researchers “stop people as they’re coming in and out of specific buildings, and you actually ask them,” said Teague. Other potential methods being discussed include special surveys and travel journals.

Monitoring and measuring are crucial not only for improving the program in San Francisco but in demonstrating its viability elsewhere. San Francisco’s plan differs from other cities that use voluntary measures, often in conjunction with employers. Might this be the beginning of a new standard practice?

“We definitely have received a lot of feedback from other municipalities, other jurisdictions who have a lot of interest in the program,” said Teague. The new plan may thus be the start of a trend that gets more out of public transit, biking, and walkability, making for healthier, happier cities.

Original Article: https://mobilitylab.org/2018/04/03/san-francisco-uses-parking-spaces-gamify-mobility/?utm_source=%23132+-+April+15%2C+2018&utm_campaign=%23132&utm_medium=email

Functional streetlights are critical to pedestrian safety. If you’ve noticed a streetlight outage in University Circle, let us know u...

Functional streetlights are critical to pedestrian safety. If you’ve noticed a streetlight outage in University Circle, let us know using our report form: universitycircle.org/report-streetlight-outages

Functional streetlights are critical to pedestrian safety. If you’ve noticed a streetlight outage in University Circle, let us know using our report form: universitycircle.org/report-streetlight-outages

Monday, August 8 2022 | 10:00am

Tuesday, July 19 2022 | 10:07am

Take advantage of the warm weather and plan your next trip to University Circle by bike! Check out our bike rack map to find a secure b...

Take advantage of the warm weather and plan your next trip to University Circle by bike! Check out our bike rack map to find a secure bike parking location near your destination: ugointhecircle.com/bikeracks

Take advantage of the warm weather and plan your next trip to University Circle by bike! Check out our bike rack map to find a secure bike parking location near your destination: ugointhecircle.com/bikeracks

Friday, July 15 2022 | 12:00pm

As part of @universitycircle's Project Yield initiative, close call reporting is a key part of understanding road safety at the neighbo...

As part of @universitycircle's Project Yield initiative, close call reporting is a key part of understanding road safety at the neighborhood level. If you experience or witness a “close call” incident, please let us know by reporting it here: universitycircle.org/project-yield

As part of @universitycircle's Project Yield initiative, close call reporting is a key part of understanding road safety at the neighborhood level. If you experience or witness a “close call” incident, please let us know by reporting it here: universitycircle.org/project-yield

Tuesday, June 28 2022 | 12:00pm

If you notice debris or other hazards in a bike lane, you can report it. Call the @cityofcleveland 3-1-1 line to report it on weekdays ...

If you notice debris or other hazards in a bike lane, you can report it. Call the @cityofcleveland 3-1-1 line to report it on weekdays during business hours.

If you notice debris or other hazards in a bike lane, you can report it. Call the @cityofcleveland 3-1-1 line to report it on weekdays during business hours.

Tuesday, June 14 2022 | 9:05am

Attending #SummerArtsFest this Saturday? Consider biking! @ohiocitycycles will have a bike parking corral at Wade Oval across the stree...

Attending #SummerArtsFest this Saturday? Consider biking! @ohiocitycycles will have a bike parking corral at Wade Oval across the street from the Cleveland Museum of Art. See event information and our suggested bike routes for getting there: https://t.co/WUCvon8AGi

Attending #SummerArtsFest this Saturday? Consider biking! @ohiocitycycles will have a bike parking corral at Wade Oval across the street from the Cleveland Museum of Art. See event information and our suggested bike routes for getting there: https://t.co/WUCvon8AGi

Thursday, June 9 2022 | 11:07am

Keep up to date with road closures, construction, bus route changes, and more with our transportation alerts. Sign up for this essentia...

Keep up to date with road closures, construction, bus route changes, and more with our transportation alerts. Sign up for this essential feature at ugointhecircle.com/alerts

Keep up to date with road closures, construction, bus route changes, and more with our transportation alerts. Sign up for this essential feature at ugointhecircle.com/alerts

Tuesday, June 7 2022 | 4:01pm

This Friday is World Bicycle Day! Consider biking to work and/or take advantage of more than 5 miles of dedicated bike lanes and off-ro...

This Friday is World Bicycle Day! Consider biking to work and/or take advantage of more than 5 miles of dedicated bike lanes and off-road paths that go through University Circle. Find our biking routes and resources here: ugointhecircle.com/transportation-options/biking . . . #uGointhecircle #InThe...

This Friday is World Bicycle Day! Consider biking to work and/or take advantage of more than 5 miles of dedicated bike lanes and off-road paths that go through University Circle. Find our biking routes and resources here: ugointhecircle.com/transportation-options/biking . . . #uGointhecircle #InTheCircle #UniversityCircle #uGObybike #bikecleveland #clevelandbikes #WorldBicycleDay

Wednesday, June 1 2022 | 11:03am

Insta, meet Sue! Sue is a student @CWRU and commutes from downtown. She thinks finding parking on campus is stressful. "I take the Heal...

Insta, meet Sue! Sue is a student @CWRU and commutes from downtown. She thinks finding parking on campus is stressful. "I take the HealthLine because it's faster and I'm saving money on gas. I'm a big fan of public transit." #uGOinthecircle #commuterstory #UniversityCircle #iGoRTA #AlternativeTrans...

Insta, meet Sue! Sue is a student @CWRU and commutes from downtown. She thinks finding parking on campus is stressful. "I take the HealthLine because it's faster and I'm saving money on gas. I'm a big fan of public transit." #uGOinthecircle #commuterstory #UniversityCircle #iGoRTA #AlternativeTransportation #CLE #NEOhio #NortheastOhio #PublicTransportation #Transit #rideRTA #testimonial

Friday, January 21 2022 | 9:45am

Insta, meet Maria! Maria works at the Cleveland Clinic, lives in South Euclid, and has taken the bus to work for the last 48 years. "I ...

Insta, meet Maria! Maria works at the Cleveland Clinic, lives in South Euclid, and has taken the bus to work for the last 48 years. "I don’t like driving, the bus is much easier, especially in the winter since you don’t have to worry about slipping and sliding." Ride on, Maria! #uGOinthecircl...

Insta, meet Maria! Maria works at the Cleveland Clinic, lives in South Euclid, and has taken the bus to work for the last 48 years. "I don’t like driving, the bus is much easier, especially in the winter since you don’t have to worry about slipping and sliding." Ride on, Maria! #uGOinthecircle #commuterstory #UniversityCircle #iGoRTA #AlternativeTransportation #CLE #NEOhio #NortheastOhio #PublicTransportation #Transit #rideRTA #testimonial

Friday, January 7 2022 | 9:45am

In honor of national trivia day 🧐 ...and step counters everywhere! #NationalTriviaDay #PublicTransit #Shuttles #TDM #sustainabletr...

In honor of national trivia day 🧐 ...and step counters everywhere! #NationalTriviaDay #PublicTransit #Shuttles #TDM #sustainabletransportation #urbanmobility #healthyliving #newyearsresolutions

In honor of national trivia day 🧐 ...and step counters everywhere! #NationalTriviaDay #PublicTransit #Shuttles #TDM #sustainabletransportation #urbanmobility #healthyliving #newyearsresolutions

Tuesday, January 4 2022 | 10:45am

All the best for a happy, healthy and prosperous 2022!

All the best for a happy, healthy and prosperous 2022!

All the best for a happy, healthy and prosperous 2022!

Saturday, January 1 2022 | 9:00am

Wednesday, December 15 2021 | 11:38am

Biking reduces stress as well as the risks of heart disease and stroke. Find biking routes and resources to help you get out on two whe...

Biking reduces stress as well as the risks of heart disease and stroke. Find biking routes and resources to help you get out on two wheels!

Biking reduces stress as well as the risks of heart disease and stroke. Find biking routes and resources to help you get out on two wheels!

Sunday, October 10 2021 | 6:00pm

Another day, another demo! Thanks to everyone who came out to get a free helmet and test ride courtesy of @ridespin. Come back out on...

Another day, another demo! Thanks to everyone who came out to get a free helmet and test ride courtesy of @ridespin. Come back out on Monday 9/11 at 6:30 to join @slowrollcleveland for a social ride through the neighborhood. #sharedmobility #safety #bikesafety #scooters #urbanmobility #bikecleve...

Another day, another demo! Thanks to everyone who came out to get a free helmet and test ride courtesy of @ridespin. Come back out on Monday 9/11 at 6:30 to join @slowrollcleveland for a social ride through the neighborhood. #sharedmobility #safety #bikesafety #scooters #urbanmobility #bikecleveland

Friday, October 8 2021 | 5:21pm

Thursday, September 30 2021 | 2:54pm

Get spooky next month and mix up your driving commute! The “Lake Eerie” Challenge starts October 1. Register at gohiocommute.com, t...

Get spooky next month and mix up your driving commute! The “Lake Eerie” Challenge starts October 1. Register at gohiocommute.com, then bike, walk, bus, carpool or telecommute in the month of October, log your trips, and win great prizes.

Get spooky next month and mix up your driving commute! The “Lake Eerie” Challenge starts October 1. Register at gohiocommute.com, then bike, walk, bus, carpool or telecommute in the month of October, log your trips, and win great prizes.

Tuesday, September 28 2021 | 2:37pm

85.5% of employees in University Circle get to work by driving alone. Check out our employer incentives page to see if your employer of...

85.5% of employees in University Circle get to work by driving alone. Check out our employer incentives page to see if your employer offers benefits for sustainable transit. https://www.ugointhecircle.com/benefits/employer-incentives

85.5% of employees in University Circle get to work by driving alone. Check out our employer incentives page to see if your employer offers benefits for sustainable transit. https://www.ugointhecircle.com/benefits/employer-incentives

Sunday, September 19 2021 | 6:15pm

Navigating the Circle from out of town, or the nearby suburbs can be tough! Use our trip planner to get the best directions for you. Wh...

Navigating the Circle from out of town, or the nearby suburbs can be tough! Use our trip planner to get the best directions for you. Whether you're biking, walking, carpooling, or driving we can help. #LinkInBio

Navigating the Circle from out of town, or the nearby suburbs can be tough! Use our trip planner to get the best directions for you. Whether you're biking, walking, carpooling, or driving we can help. #LinkInBio

Saturday, September 11 2021 | 12:55pm

One last chance to ‘Dine & Dash’ with us! Wednesday, August 25 at noon we’re talking shared e-scooters with representatives from...

One last chance to ‘Dine & Dash’ with us! Wednesday, August 25 at noon we’re talking shared e-scooters with representatives from the @cityofcleveland and @ridespin. Don’t wait to register! #sustainabletransportation #TDM #scooters #sharedmobility #universitycircle #uGO #DineandDash

One last chance to ‘Dine & Dash’ with us! Wednesday, August 25 at noon we’re talking shared e-scooters with representatives from the @cityofcleveland and @ridespin. Don’t wait to register! #sustainabletransportation #TDM #scooters #sharedmobility #universitycircle #uGO #DineandDash

Thursday, August 12 2021 | 11:13am

The average commuter to University Circle spends 9 days per year commuting. Join our Dine & Dash on ridematching for tips on revamping ...

The average commuter to University Circle spends 9 days per year commuting. Join our Dine & Dash on ridematching for tips on revamping your commute! #sustainabletransportation #greencommute #carpool #ridematching #TDM

The average commuter to University Circle spends 9 days per year commuting. Join our Dine & Dash on ridematching for tips on revamping your commute! #sustainabletransportation #greencommute #carpool #ridematching #TDM

Wednesday, July 28 2021 | 10:26am

Tuesday, June 22 2021 | 9:05am

At the next Dine & Dash virtual info session on sustainable transportation, we’re talking with community advocate and certified cycli...

At the next Dine & Dash virtual info session on sustainable transportation, we’re talking with community advocate and certified cycling instructor Diana Hildebrand with @devahd cycling on tips for improving confidence on two wheels. Join us! #biking #confidentcycling #dineanddash #leagueofamerica...

At the next Dine & Dash virtual info session on sustainable transportation, we’re talking with community advocate and certified cycling instructor Diana Hildebrand with @devahd cycling on tips for improving confidence on two wheels. Join us! #biking #confidentcycling #dineanddash #leagueofamericanbicyclists #LCI #sustainabletransportation #urbanmobility

Monday, June 14 2021 | 2:44pm

At the next Dine & Dash virtual info session on sustainable transportation, we’re talking RTA bus route changes, real time bus info a...

At the next Dine & Dash virtual info session on sustainable transportation, we’re talking RTA bus route changes, real time bus info and tips for new riders with staff from @ridertacleveland. Those who register will be entered into a raffle for a uGO to lunch ($40 value) prize pack. Join us! Regis...

At the next Dine & Dash virtual info session on sustainable transportation, we’re talking RTA bus route changes, real time bus info and tips for new riders with staff from @ridertacleveland. Those who register will be entered into a raffle for a uGO to lunch ($40 value) prize pack. Join us! Registration details are available at uGOinthecircle.com/events #publictransit #sustainabletransportation #universitycircle #commute #transit #transitcommute

Tuesday, May 4 2021 | 11:41am

Learn how your commute can be greener, more productive and less expensive at our fist uGO Dine & Dash session on the topic of vanpool o...

Learn how your commute can be greener, more productive and less expensive at our fist uGO Dine & Dash session on the topic of vanpool on Thursday, April 22nd at noon! Registration details are available at: uGOinthecircle.com/events

Learn how your commute can be greener, more productive and less expensive at our fist uGO Dine & Dash session on the topic of vanpool on Thursday, April 22nd at noon! Registration details are available at: uGOinthecircle.com/events

Tuesday, April 13 2021 | 11:56am

Stay Connected

Sign up to receive alerts and/or uGO's seldom email communications.

Calculate Your Commute

How much are you spending on your way to work?

Show Me

Stay Connected! Sign up to receive transportation alerts and stay up to date on uGO news.

Photo Gallery

1 of 22